Could jonah have been swallowed by a whale?

12
Annalise Wunsch asked a question: Could jonah have been swallowed by a whale?
Asked By: Annalise Wunsch
Date created: Thu, Apr 22, 2021 12:14 PM
Date updated: Tue, Jun 28, 2022 1:31 AM

Content

Video answer: A fish or a whale? here's what swallowed jonah.

A fish or a whale? here's what swallowed jonah.

Top best answers to the question «Could jonah have been swallowed by a whale»

He concludes that "the whale shark is not the fish that swallowed Jonah." Sperm whales regularly eat giant squid, so they could swallow a human. Similar to a cow, sperm whales have four-chambered stomachs. The first chamber has no gastric juices but has muscular walls to crush its food.

The Big fish that swallowed Jonah is often said to be a whale, however the Bible does not make it clear at all… We can assume that a human would be spat out too as the whale shark would know it cannot swallow it. There have been reports of Great White Sharks and Groupers large enough to swallow a man.

He concludes that "the whale shark is not the fish that swallowed Jonah." Sperm whales regularly eat giant squid, so they could swallow a human… On the other hand, it is not possible to breathe inside the sperm whale's stomach because there is no air (but probably methane instead).

FAQ

Those who are looking for an answer to the question «Could jonah have been swallowed by a whale?» often ask the following questions:

🌴 How was jonah swallowed by a whale?

Last Friday, a humpback whale almost swallowed Michael Packard. The commercial lobster diver was in the whale's mouth for 30 to 40 seconds before the humpback spat him back out. He quickly realized that he was actually inside the whale's mouth…

🌴 Was jonah really swallowed by a whale?

Jonah is miraculously saved by being swallowed by a large fish, in whose belly he spends three days and three nights. While in the great fish, Jonah prays to God in his affliction and commits to giving thanks and to paying what he has vowed. God then commands the fish to vomit Jonah out.

🌴 Was jonah truly swallowed by a whale?

Answer. The book of Jonah recounts the story of a disobedient prophet who, upon being swallowed by a whale (or a “great fish”) and vomited upon the shore, reluctantly led the reprobate city of Nineveh to repentance. The Bible’s plain teaching is that, yes, Jonah was truly swallowed by a whale (or a great fish).

Video answer: Was jonah swallowed by a whale? (april 29, 2021)

Was jonah swallowed by a whale? (april 29, 2021)

9 other answers

Furthermore, there have been several reported cases of modern sailors or other individuals swallowed by such an animal, only to be recovered many hours later. But again, this story involves the miraculous. It may be that Jonah actually died and was resurrected by God. This is implied in his description of his experience especially Jonah 2:2.

Mosaic depicting Jonah being swallowed by a fish, Huqoq synagogue. Daniel Esparza - published on 07/15/21 Prophets have not always been called prophets — not even in the Bible.

In the Bible, Jonah is swallowed by a great fish when he disobeys God’s instructions to preach salvation to the people of Nineveh. Legend has held that this big fish was a whale. Take a look at this video! Maybe it was a shark. Though we don’t know for sure, one thing is certain.

There is always some air in the whale’s stomach, and, as long as the animal it has swallowed is still alive, digestive activity will not begin. Thus, Jonah’s experience could possibly have happened entirely with the framework of natural law.

Henry Morris wrote, “It could have been…a large whale-shark, or possibly some now-extinct marine reptile.” 2 Although knowing the animal’s exact identity is not necessary to understand the Jonah passages, its proper identification would add an element of historicity to the prophet’s traumatic experiences.

According to historian Edward Davis, the story may have been inspired by the Gorleston whale, a 30ft rorqual or baleen whale killed near Great Yarmouth in June 1981.

Jonah is the greatest sign and type of the risen Christ, he rose from the dead after 3 days(Matt 12:40). Did James Bartley really get swallowed by a whale and survive in the early part of last century? Probably not, who cares...but if God supernaturally saved his creation from death and recorded it in his Book...it seems wise to believe him!

“There are at least 2 known monsters of the deep that could easily have swallowed Jonah. They are the Balaenoptera Musculus or sulphur-bottom whale, and the Rhinodon Typicus or whale shark.” Neither monster has any teeth.

No, it is not physically possible for Jonah to have been swallowed by a giant water creature, fish, mammal or any other. Well, you may prove that such and such whale or such and such shark could have done the feat. But, if you can prove that Jonah could have been swallowed and kept alive by natural means, then you disprove the Bible.

Your Answer

We've handpicked 29 related questions for you, similar to «Could jonah have been swallowed by a whale?» so you can surely find the answer!

What whale swallowed nemo?

Back in the ocean, the humpback whale that swallowed Marlin and Dory is making his way through the deep blue sea. And inside his mouth, Marlin is splashing around trying to escape by ramming into the whale's baleen bristles (they look like a cross between teeth and a really huge broom).

Has anyone been swallowed by a shark?

A teacher was "swallowed alive" by a great white shark as he fished with friends in south Australia, an inquest has heard. Sam Kellet, 28, was planning to dive at a different spot 100km away from Goldsmith Beach, west of Adelaide, but a catastrophic fire warning forced them to move, ITV reported.

Has anyone been swallowed by a basking shark?

Has anyone ever been sucked up by one of these? They have massive mouths, but no, they don't swallow large items and in fact they're so sensitive to foreign objects they will move away to avoid them. They are generally slow movers but can react incredibly quickly if they need to, even breaching clear out of the water.

Could the loss of the baiji have been avoided?
  • The loss of this unique and remarkable river dolphin is a shocking tragedy that could have been avoided. It should be a wake up call, the baiji is a sentinel species, a canary in the mine - we have to redouble our efforts and energies and prevent the same fate happening to the world's surviving river dolphins.
How long did jonah live in the whale?

God purposely appointed Jonah to be swallowed by the whale and remain dead inside for exactly three days and nights.

Video answer: Was jonah really swallowed by a whale?

Was jonah really swallowed by a whale? What does jonah and the whale teach us?

The primary theme of the story of Jonah and the Whale is that God's love, grace, and compassion extend to everyone, even outsiders and oppressors. God loves all people. A secondary message is that you can't run from God. Jonah tried to run, but God stuck with him and gave Jonah a second chance.

What is the moral of jonah and the whale?

The moral of the story of Jonah and the big fish, sometimes referred to as a whale, is that a person cannot run away from God's plans.

Video answer: The whale belches jonah on a beach

The whale belches jonah on a beach Has a whale ever swallowed a human?

While the veracity of the story is in question, it is physically possible for a sperm whale to swallow a human whole, as they are known to swallow giant squid whole. However, such a person would be crushed, drowned or suffocated in the whale's stomach.

What character was swallowed by a whale?

After being cast from the ship, Jonah is swallowed by a large fish, within the belly of which he remains for three days and three nights. While in the great fish, Jonah prays to God in his affliction and commits to giving thanks and to paying what he has vowed. God then commands the fish to vomit Jonah out.

What kind of whale swallowed a man?

A humpback whale recently swallowed a Cape Cod lobster diver. This is a highly unusual event, but one expert told Live Science that there are certain types of behaviors that could have led to the man being swallowed — such as diving too close to the whale's normal food.

Video answer: Comparison: what if a whale has swallowed you

Comparison: what if a whale has swallowed you What did jonah say in the belly of the whale?

1 From inside the fish Jonah prayed to the Lord his God. 2 He said: “In my distress I called to the Lord, and he answered me.

Can you be swallowed by a blue whale?

Even if they tried to swallow a human whole, they wouldn't be able to fit a person down their throat. Blue whales won't even attempt to eat small marine mammals, let alone a human. There are no known recorded events of a blue whale ever eating or consuming a person partially or wholly except in stories and mythology.

Can you survive being swallowed by a whale?

Despite occasional reports of whales scooping people into their mouths, it's incredibly rare—and for all but one species, swallowing a human is physically impossible. On Friday, a lobster diver made headlines when he described miraculously surviving being “swallowed” by a humpback whale off Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

Can you survive getting swallowed by a whale?

When something larger than krill enters their mouths, they'll use their tongues to force it back out. As you have probably gathered by now, even though it is technically possible to survive being swallowed by a whale, it's extremely unlikely.

Can you survive if swallowed by a whale?

While the veracity of the story is in question, it is physically possible for a sperm whale to swallow a human whole, as they are known to swallow giant squid whole. However, such a person would be crushed, drowned or suffocated in the whale's stomach. Like ruminants, the sperm whale has a four-chambered stomach.

Has anyone survived being swallowed by a whale?

Despite occasional reports of whales scooping people into their mouths, it's incredibly rare—and for all but one species, swallowing a human is physically impossible. On Friday, a lobster diver made headlines when he described miraculously surviving being “swallowed” by a humpback whale off Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

Would you die if a whale swallowed you?

And suddenly you might worry that that could actually happen to you. Could a whale shark swallow you by accident? The quick answer is no.

What happens if you are swallowed by a whale?

According to one researcher, if an individual who is consumed by a boxhead whale can surpass its teeth as well as down into its tummy, the enzymes in its digestion system can melt human skin. Then, after that, there was just methane gas in the stomach of the city head whale, so people could not make it through.

Video answer: What if you were swallowed by a whale?

What if you were swallowed by a whale? What if you get swallowed by a whale shark?

The massive beast could not choke me down even if it preferred man meat to plankton. The sharks know that they can't eat you, and they often close their mouths around big prey like you or big fish. But if they did accidentally take you into their mouths, what would happen? ... Okay, so whale sharks won't swallow you.

How many whale watching tours have there been in sri lanka?
  • He has worked with many celebrated photographers from around the world, with over 300 whale watching tours in Sri Lanka.
Could a whale kill a shark?

There have been reports of killer whales attacking several species of sharks off the South African coast since 2017 and the deaths were eventually linked to two killer whales in the area.

What could kill a blue whale?

Because of their size, power and speed, adult blue whales have virtually no natural ocean predators. The only sea creature known to attack blue whales is the orca whale (scientific name: Orcinus orca) also known as the “killer whale”… However, there are very few reports of orcas actually killing blue whales.

Are there any whales that have swallowed people alive?
  • Most whales are very different from the ones depicted in fiction, i.e. Moby-Dick and Jonah's whale in the Bible. In fact, being swallowed is the least of your worries in the sea.
Could the extinction of the baiji river dolphin been avoided?
  • For the sake of the world's surviving river dolphin species, it is essential that we do not forget the extinct baiji, and the man-made reasons for its extinction. The loss of this unique and remarkable river dolphin is a shocking tragedy that could have been avoided.
Has a new whale been found?

A new whale species may have been discovered off a remote island in Mexico. A team of beaked whale researchers are “highly confident” that they have likely identified a new species of whale off Mexico's western coast… This particular type of beaked whale had unusual teeth placement, researcher Jay Barlow told Reuters.

Video answer: How to survive getting swallowed by a whale

How to survive getting swallowed by a whale